Hocking County's Independent Insurance Agency — Locally Owned Since 1959
We represent seven carriers so you get real options, not a single company's best offer. Personal, business, life, and Medicare coverage from an agency that's been on South Market Street since before most of our carriers existed.
• 65+ Years Serving Logan and Hocking County • 4.9-Star Google Rating • 7 Carrier Portfolio
• 65+ Years Serving Logan and Hocking County • 4.9-Star Google Rating • 7 Carrier Portfolio
Two Founding Families, Still Active Today
We're not a call center. We're not a national brand with a local phone number. Logan Insurance Agency is an independent agency that has operated out of downtown Logan since 1959 — multi-generational, community-rooted, and licensed to represent seven different insurance carriers on your behalf.
That independence is the difference. When you call us, we're not limited to one company's rates or one set of policy terms. We compare options across American Modern, Auto-Owners, Cincinnati Insurance, Foremost, Hastings, Progressive, and West Bend to find coverage that actually fits what you need and what you're willing to spend.
Learn more about what it means to work with an independent agent on our Independent Advantage page.
Coverage for Every Part of Your Life in Hocking County
Business Insurance
Life & Health Insurance
See What Our Clients Say
Seven Carriers. One Agent. You Get Options.
Most insurance buyers don't realize that a captive agent — someone who works for a single company — can only offer you that company's rates and terms. If it's not a fit, your only option is to look elsewhere on your own.
As an independent agency, we hold appointments with seven carriers and shop your coverage across all of them. That means when we bring you a quote, it's already been compared. You're not guessing whether you got a fair rate. We've done that work before the conversation starts.
Our carrier portfolio includes American Modern, Auto-Owners, Cincinnati Insurance, Foremost, Hastings, Progressive, and West Bend — a mix of regional and national carriers with strong claims reputations and competitive pricing across personal and commercial lines.
A Specialty Built for Hocking Hills Property Owners
If you own a vacation cabin or short-term rental property in the Hocking Hills area, standard homeowners insurance almost certainly doesn't cover how that property is used. We've built a statewide specialty in short-term rental and vacation cabin insurance, and we serve property owners across all 88 Ohio counties.
It's one of the more complex coverage problems in personal lines — and it's one we know well.
Frequently Asked Questions About Logan Insurance Agency
Is Logan Insurance Agency a local or national company?
We're a locally owned, independent agency based in downtown Logan, Ohio, at 53 S. Market St. We've been in continuous operation since 1959 under multi-generational family ownership. We are not affiliated with any national insurance brand or franchise.
What does it mean that you're an independent agency?
It means we represent multiple insurance carriers rather than a single company. We hold appointments with seven carriers and can shop your coverage across all of them to find the best combination of price, coverage, and carrier reputation for your situation.
What areas do you serve?
Our primary service area is Logan and Hocking County, including Rockbridge, Laurelville, South Bloomingville, Nelsonville, Haydenville, and surrounding communities. For short-term rental and vacation cabin insurance, we serve property owners across all 88 Ohio counties.
How do I get a quote?
You can request a quote online, call or text us at (740) 385-8575, or stop by our office at 53 S. Market St. in Logan during business hours. We're a walk-in-friendly office — no appointment required for most inquiries.
Do you help with Medicare coverage?
Yes. We work with Medicare-eligible individuals throughout Hocking County and southeastern Ohio, covering Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and Part D prescription drug plans. If you're turning 65 or reviewing your current Medicare coverage, we can walk you through your options at no cost to you.
